top of page
Search

Why Do We Keep Having the Same Argument?

3 days ago
2 min read

By John and Sheridan Fisher


It starts with the dishes. One of you says, “I guess I’m doing these again.” The other says, “I was going to get to them.” Within minutes, you’re arguing about who does more, who appreciates whom, and what happened last Saturday. The dishes are still in the sink.


The subject can change from chores to money or time together. What’s worth noticing is the order of events. If the conversation keeps ending in the same place, look at what each of you does just before it gets there.


Replay the first minute

Pick a disagreement you both remember and walk through the opening. What was said? What did each of you hear in it? What did you do next?


In the dishes example, one partner might hear, “You think I’m lazy,” and start defending themselves. The other might hear that defense as, “You still don’t see how much I’m doing,” and bring up another example. It’s easy to see why both people keep talking and neither feels heard.


Say what you were hoping your partner would hear

The person at the sink might say, “I’m worn out, and I’d like you to handle the kitchen tonight.” The other might say, “I can do that. When I heard ‘again,’ I got defensive because I thought we were talking about everything I’ve ever forgotten.”


Once both people have said what was going on for them, there’s a specific decision to make. Who’s handling the kitchen tonight? If the workload itself feels unfair, set aside time to talk through the week and agree on who owns which tasks.


Pick one thing to try next time

Ask each other, “How will we know this conversation is starting to go the way it usually does?” It might be the moment one of you says “always,” brings up last Saturday, or stops answering. When you notice it, try asking, “What are we trying to decide right now?” Then let each person answer.

In marital coaching, we start with a real conversation from your relationship.


We walk through what happened, help each of you put words to what you were trying to say, and choose one change to try together.


Have a conversation you’re tired of repeating? Tell us a little about what keeps coming up.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page